|
Are
you monitoring your service base?
Can you answer the following questions regarding your active
service base (MIF)?
Is your base growing or shrinking?
Do you know how many machines were placed last month?
How many were net new? How many were upgrades?
Is the product mix of your service base changing?
Do you know how many service contracts were cancelled
last month and not replaced?
What effect have changes in your service base had on your
staffing requirements?
What will the effect be on your aftermarket revenue stream?
How will your parts spend be impacted by changes in your base?
Monitoring the service base is one of the most underutilized
elements of business intelligence today, and it is vital to
running a smart service department. More often than not, I find
that dealers are not tracking their active service base, or MIF.
Consequently, many service departments are suffering from the
well-known boiled frog syndrome, meaning, their service base has
been changing slowly over time with no awareness of the impact of
the change most notably, the impact on workload and staffing
requirements.
So, what events and activities impact your service base? Here are
the most common:
Net new equipment sales
Upgrades or churn
Outright cancellations/removals
T&M to contract conversions
Competitive contract takeovers
Whats the potential impact of these events to service?
Net new placements obviously a good thing because they bring
incremental click volume and aftermarket (service & supply)
revenue. New placements also drive incremental service workload
and parts cost.
Upgrades or churn can, and usually does, result in decreased
revenue driven by a lower mil rate. This is a business reality
that must be quantified and comprehended.
Outright cancellations obviously a bad thing, which results in
revenue and workload loss.
If you tracked events that impact your service base and the
resulting base changes, what else might it tell you?
It can provide insight into what is driving your revenue growth,
or lack thereof
It can provide trend data to better forecast staffing
requirements
It can tell you if and when you are losing deals to the
competition
It can help assess the impact or effectiveness of sales
compensation plans, i.e., net new business vs upgrades
It can provide a means for measuring customer retention
How can you track changes in your base?
A quick and easy way to track ongoing changes in your service base
with virtually any ERP system involves the use of special service
call types. Specifically, establish bookmark service call types
for installation and cancellation activity previously discussed.
These bookmark service calls can be entered by contract personnel
as they enter new contracts, upgrades, and cancellations. The
bookmark call types should be ranged so that they do not show up
under normal service reporting use numeric call types or types
beginning with Z. Bookmark service calls can be assigned to a
service manager, or anyone who does not take service calls. Here
are examples of installation and cancellation bookmark call types:
0101 New placement new customer or incremental placement in
existing account
0102 Upgrade new machine
0103 New contract competitive takeover
0104 T&M conversion to contract existing customer
0201 Cancellation upgrade, replaced by new equipment
0202 Cancellation equipment consolidation
0203 Cancellation M/A cost, not replaced
0204 Cancellation equipment obsolete, not replaced
0205 Cancellation lost to competition
Once these call types are set up and in use, monthly and quarterly
service call activity reports can be generated for these call
types only. Following is a simple summary report that can then be
used to track activity levels:
Feb 2010 Service Base Activity Report
New Installations 25
Upgrade Installation 15
Interterritorial Installation 3
- Total Installations 43
Cancellation - Upgrades 15
Cancellation - Obsolete 2
Cancellation - Cost 1
Cancellation - lost to comp 1
- Total Cancellations 19
Net Change + 24
In this example, we find that 65% of the equipment installations
were net new placements and 35% were upgrades that replaced
existing equipment. 79% of the equipment cancellations (removals)
were not replaced and 5% were lost to a competitor. The base
retention rate for the month was 79%.
Generally speaking, in todays industry climate, upgrades account
for a high percentage of base change activity. As previously
mentioned, upgrade activity can have a significant impact on the
service side of the business and must be comprehended. Lets look
at this again.
Potential impact of upgrades on service:
When a large percentage of new placements are replacing older
models with high service rates, total revenue may remain flat or
decline.
Workload (manpower) requirements are generally reduced with the
increased reliability of new equipment (as much as a 15% impact,
depending on models). This can, and commonly does, result in
excess capacity (cost) if not managed. You may not need to add
people if you are in a growth mode, i.e., getting into MPS.
Generally, parts cost will decrease (as much as a 25% impact,
depending on models). A decrease in parts cost, driven by newer
equipment placements, can mask other parts spend
issues/opportunities. It is critical to quantify and manage to the
impact of churn on parts spend.
If your service performance metrics scenario looks similar to the
following, theres a good chance changes in your service base are
impacting your results and now is the time for action.
Service revenue is declining, or flat
Labor cost as a percentage of revenue is increasing
Parts cost as a percentage of revenue is declining
Service GP percentage is below 52% benchmark and steady or
declining
Response time has improved over time, and possibly better than
the four-hour benchmark
Productive hours per tech is low, possibly less than 5hrs/day
Heres the bottom line: Monitoring your service base AND managing
to the impact of base changes is a critical success factor in the
drive for achieving and sustaining benchmark (52%+) service
margins. DO IT NOW!
Mike Woodard is a consultant with Strategy Development, an imaging
industry management consulting firm. Mike has 30+ years experience
in all aspects of field service operations and service strategy
development. During his 20 years with IKON Office Solutions, Mike
held key regional and national service operations positions
including National VP, Field Service Strategy; National VP, Field
Services; and National VP, Field Service Operations. Prior to
joining IKON, Mike spent 18 years with Xerox Corporation in
multiple field service assignments. Mike advises companies on
critical success factors including: target service metrics and
goals, performance management, technology application, service
growth strategies, and compensation and incentives. Mike can be
reached at:
woodard@strategydevelopment.org or 610.742.4701.
|